You need to earn 10 or more new, positive reviews during the campaign period (Jan. 1 to Oct. 31, 2017); and maintain a 3.5-5 average rating during that time period. To know if you have met these requirements:
First, make sure you already have claimed your nonprofit profile.
Log in at https://greatnonprofits.org/signin. After logging in, it will take you to the Nonprofit Stats page if you only have one claimed nonprofit. If you have claimed more than one nonprofit, it will show you the list (click the one you want to manage).
Note: If you are not taken to the Nonprofit Stats page after you are logged in, click the welcome greeting in the header and select Manage My Nonprofit.
On the Nonprofit Stats page, click the Top-Rated Status link.